Feedback (comment/underline) section to be improved

For @VictoriaDemierbe, it is not easy to check if the learner has spotted her remarks/underlining. She has flagged some things that Tyler didn't change - the conversation kept going (that is great), but some elements that could be useful to discuss were dropped. Tyler was not able to react to the comments to show that he had made note of them. (And again, preserving the old text with strikethrough when correcting a flagged error is useful for recalling what the mistake was.)

It would then be useful to get a specific notification when something has been flagged or commented on, so we know to look at it. (Especially if we have sent other messages in the meantime, we'd have to scroll up to see the flag/comment, which we wouldn't do if we don't know we need to.)

• Tyler notices that there is a white sidebar to the right of the chat field, but nothing is displayed in it. Perhaps this space could be a 'notepad' shared between the tutor and student for meta discussion? When something is flagged or commented on, it could show up in this sidebar. This then creates a separate chat thread for correcting, discussing corrections, asking, explaining, etc., without interrupting the flow of the conversation in the main thread.

added Open for discussion label

mentioned in issue #103 (closed)

mentioned in issue #67 (closed)

mentioned in issue #101 (closed)

mentioned in issue #93 (closed)

mentioned in issue #87 (closed)

Might be useful to be able to edit underlines: I made a mistake at some point, I wanted to underline a part of Tyler's message, and I was not able to delete my underline...

And she was then not able to add a comment to the mistakenly underlined word.

added To do label and removed Open for discussion label

changed milestone to %0.2: Essential functions ready & corrective feedback

added UX label

How would you see this feature? To simplify, I would (at least for the first version) only allow to delete a comment/underline, rather than a complete edit feature. But how would you see it, in term of user experience?

I see multiple possibilities, but I don't like so much any of them.

• Click on a comment/underline to remove it (with a confirmation box)
• add a cross after every comment/underline, directly in the text, to remove it
• create a dedicated menu to see and remove comments/underline
• add a X at the end of the comment's box, but then how to manage underlines?

I'm open to any other suggestion.

When we mouse over a comment, the comment shows up in a little pop-up bubble. Could there be 'edit' and 'bin' icons on that bubble?

How would you handle underline?

also popup bubble on mouse hover on underline -> only "x" in the popup

Call 15/11/2024

To handle underlines, we can display an empty comment with just the arrow to remove it.

added Open for discussion label and removed To do label

assigned to @bridubois

unassigned @bridubois

added To do label and removed Open for discussion label

assigned to @dvanrossum

unassigned @dvanrossum

assigned to @bridubois

closed with commit 228bf3ff

mentioned in commit 228bf3ff